Skip to content
Utah Business AIWhere Utah business connects.

Amendment B: a 60% vote for tax-raising initiatives

Ballot question: "Shall the Utah Constitution be amended to require that citizen-proposed laws that increase taxes compared to existing law be approved by at least 60% of voters, instead of a simple majority?"

At a glanceLaws

01At a glance

Type
Legislatively referred constitutional amendment
Proposed by
S.J.R. 2, 2025 General Session
Would change
Article VI, Section 1 (initiatives)
On the ballot
November 3, 2026, statewide
Passes with
A simple majority of voters
Status
Projected to fail (AP); unofficial until the Nov. 23 canvass
Official text and analysis
Voter pamphlet (PDF)

02What it does

Today: a statewide citizen initiative becomes law when more people vote for it than against it. Initiatives about taking wildlife already need two-thirds.

Amendment B: statewide initiatives voted on after November 1, 2026 would need at least 60% if they:

  • create a new tax;
  • expand an existing tax to cover more items or transactions;
  • raise an existing tax rate; or
  • change a property tax rate so it falls less than it would under existing law.

Not affected: laws passed by the Legislature, which still need a simple majority; county, city, and town initiatives; and initiatives that don't raise taxes.

Source: impartial analysis, voter pamphlet

03The text and what it changes

It adds a new subsection, (2)(a)(iii), to Article VI, Section 1, which gives the people the power to propose laws by initiative. The new subsection says that, despite the general majority rule, tax-raising initiated legislation "shall be adopted upon approval of at least 60% of those voting on the legislation."

The majority rule for other initiatives, the two-thirds wildlife rule, and local initiative rules stay as they are. If approved, it would have taken effect November 23, 2026. The official code already lists this as a contingent version of Art. VI, §1. Source: full text, voter pamphlet

04Sponsors and who decides

Who proposed it

  • The Utah Legislature, by joint resolution S.J.R. 2 in 2025. A constitutional amendment needs a two-thirds vote of each chamber to reach the ballot.
  • The official argument for it was written by Sen. Lincoln Fillmore and Rep. Jason Kyle; the argument against by Sen. Luz Escamilla and Rep. Angela Romero.

Who decides

  • Utah voters, statewide. A simple majority adopts it.
  • The governor doesn't sign or veto constitutional amendments.
  • The state canvass certifies the result on November 23, 2026.

05Status and timeline

  1. The Legislature passed S.J.R. 2: Senate 21–8, House 55–17.
  2. Utahns Protecting Our Constitution began buying TV ads against it (FOX 13).
  3. Poll: 34% for, 56% against (Noble Predictive Insights).
  4. Election Day. The Associated Press projected it would fail at about 9:30 PM.
  5. Unofficial count: 61.2% against, 38.8% for.
  6. State canvass certifies the final result.

06Votes

Your lawmakersChamberVote
Heidi BalderreeState Senate, District 22Yes
Stephanie GriciusState House, District 50Yes
Todd WeilerState Senate, District 8Yes

Full chamber: Senate 21 yes, 8 no. House 55 yes, 17 no, 3 absent. Bill page and roll calls. Voters: 38.8% yes, 61.2% no (unofficial).

07Cost

Cost to the state: the pamphlet's fiscal analysis says it "likely would not materially impact" state revenue or spending.

Source: voter pamphlet

08Arguments for and against

For

Sen. Lincoln Fillmore and Rep. Jason Kyle

  • Taxes affect every Utahn, so new taxes should need broad support from the people who pay them.
  • Initiatives are written only by their backers, with no public input on details, and can be undone only by another costly initiative. Legislators can be voted out.
  • It keeps the initiative process and doesn't block tax increases with strong support. Many Utah funding measures have passed 60%.
  • Their rebuttal: it limits well-funded campaigns, some backed from out of state, from raising taxes by razor-thin margins.

Against

Sen. Luz Escamilla and Rep. Angela Romero

  • It's an attack on the people's constitutional right to make laws directly. Their closing line: "Do not be fooled, this is a power grab."
  • It would make initiatives harder to use and could later be extended to other subjects.
  • The Legislature can pass similar laws by simple majority, so voters should face the same standard.
  • Their rebuttal: it creates an unequal system and could set a precedent for higher thresholds on redistricting, health care, or education.

Source: voter pamphlet. Summarized; each side wrote its own.

09Money and support

GroupSideReported spendingFunding, as reported
Utahns Protecting Our ConstitutionAgainstMore than $3 millionMailers, radio, TV, and social media. More than half its money came from The Fairness Project, a Washington, D.C. nonprofit that doesn't disclose its donors. 30 of 36 donors were from Utah, but they gave about one in five dollars.
Americans for Prosperity (Utah)ForAbout $100,000On the amendment, out of about $337,000 spent this year.
Taxpayer Shield PACForAbout $20,000Formed by the Utah Taxpayers Association.

Also urging a no vote: Alliance for Better Utah, Elevate Utah, and Better Boundaries. Also urging a yes vote: the Utah Taxpayers Association and several Republican lawmakers. These figures come from news reports of campaign filings (Salt Lake Tribune, KSL, FOX 13), not from this site's own review. The filings themselves are on the Lieutenant Governor's disclosure search.

The TV ads against Amendment B came from Utahns Protecting Our Constitution, which FOX 13 reported began buying ads in September. Its spokesperson, Scott Cuthbertson, told KSL the campaign was "entirely driven by Utah families and taxpayers."

How opinion moved

PollForAgainstNote
Early September 2026About 50%21%The rest undecided
October 26–27, 202634%56%527 likely voters, ±4.27 points. Against: 82% of Democrats, 58% of independents, 48% of Republicans.
Unofficial result38.8%61.2%State results, not final until November 23

Source: Noble Predictive Insights, via the Salt Lake Tribune. Polls are estimates with a margin of error. The shift came after opponents' ad campaign began, but a poll can't show what caused it.

10Background

The Legislature placed it on the ballot in its 2025 General Session. It's part of a longer debate over citizen initiatives that followed three narrow 2018 votes:

2018 initiativeYes voteWould it have met 60%?
Proposition 4, independent redistricting50.3%No, though it didn't raise taxes, so Amendment B wouldn't have applied
Medical marijuana52.7%No
Medicaid expansion, funded by a sales tax increase53.3%No

Only tax-raising initiatives would have needed 60%. Supporters, such as Rep. Jordan Teuscher, said it "protects the taxpayers." Opponents, such as Better Boundaries' Elizabeth Rasmussen, called the tax framing a "scare tactic." Sources: KUER, Ballotpedia

11What happens next

  • Counties finish counting, and the state canvass certifies results on November 23.
  • If the result holds, Article VI stays as it is: tax-raising initiatives still need a simple majority.
  • The Legislature could propose a different amendment in a future session. Any change would go to voters again.

13Sources

This page uses the same measure template as every bill, law, ordinance, policy, and procedure on this site, so you can compare them. Sections that don't apply are left out. Results are unofficial until the November 23 canvass. This page describes the measure and doesn't recommend a position. Checked November 6, 2026.

Constitutional amendmentStatewide · November 3, 2026Official voter pamphlet

Amendment B: a 60% vote for tax-raising initiatives: an independent, nonpartisan summary. Sources are linked on the page.