Judges on your ballot
Utah judges are appointed, then voters decide whether to keep them in "retention" elections. 57 judges were on Utah ballots in 2026. A state commission evaluates each one before the election.
What the evaluations found in 2026
- The Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission (JPEC) recommended that voters retain every judge on the 2026 ballots except one.
- It did not recommend retaining Weber County Justice Court Judge Trent Nelson.
- Evaluations cover legal ability, judicial temperament, and administrative skills, based on surveys of attorneys and court staff and on courtroom observation.
Sources: KPCW, October 13, 2026; Salt Lake Tribune, October 12, 2026. Results are unofficial until the November 23 canvass.
Find the judges on your ballot
- Open the commission's site, judges.utah.gov.
- Choose your county under Find Your Judge.
- Open each judge's report for the scores, survey comments, and the commission's recommendation.
Your county decides which district, juvenile, and justice court judges you see. Supreme Court and Court of Appeals judges appear statewide.
The commission's site loads its reports interactively, so this site links to them rather than copying them.
How retention works
- The Governor appoints state court judges, and the Utah Senate confirms them. Justice court judges are appointed by their city or county (Utah Constitution, Art. VIII, §8).
- Judges then face a yes-or-no retention vote: Supreme Court justices every 10 years, other judges every 6 years (Art. VIII, §9).
- A judge needs more yes than no votes to stay. The commission is separate from the courts and doesn't review individual rulings.
Related
- Utah court directory
- Judicial Conduct Commission, which handles misconduct complaints
- Glossary
Judges on your ballot: an independent, nonpartisan summary. Sources are linked on the page.